Home  >  Financial Articles and Q&A  >  What % of 401k Plans offer etfs today?

What % of 401k Plans offer etfs today?

Feb 02, 2017 by Daniel from Charlotte, NC in  |  Flag
2 Answers  |  3 Followers
Follow Question
0 votes

Very few plans offer ETFs because it's slightly more difficult to track a target asset allocation when dealing with shares (like an ETF) rather than partial shares (like a mutual fund). Also, intraday trading causes ETFs to be subject to greater order placing complexity than a fund that only trades at NAV.

But if you think about the potential benefits of an ETF, there's really no major reason to be disappointed in their absence from many plans. Here's why:

ETFs may offer a tax-efficient way to track an index, while not being required to distribute accumulated capital gains in the same way a mutual fund must. This can make a difference in taxable accounts as the ETF may be able to avoid incurring this tax on its owner. However, a 401(k) is tax deferred, so this isn't a benefit in this kind of account.

Also, ETFs trade at equity commission rates instead of mutual fund rates, which can save an investor in trading commissions. Since the trading costs in a 401(k) are embedded within the overall plan administrative expenses, this also is not much of a benefit.

1 Comment   |  Flag   |  Mar 21, 2017 from Scottsdale, AZ
Daniel

What if there were a trading platform that allowed you trade ETFs in partial shares? And allowed you to trade - commission free - twice daily rather than only at NAV at end of day? Folio Institutional is already there. ETF structure is a better mousetrap. 401k market will adapt - assimilate or die.

Flag |  Mar 22, 2017 near Charlotte, NC

1|600 characters needed characters left
0 votes

Too few in my opinion. ETFs are a great low cost alternative to mutual funds.. 401k Plan Advisors have been slow to recognize this reality. I would have expected ETFs to have become a bigger part of 401k investing by now just as it has become big part of non 401k investing. High fees including fund fees are the biggest detriment to individual retire savings. The damage that high fees cost retirees over time is immense and often undetected until it is too late to correct.

Comment   |  Flag   |  Nov 20, 2017

1|600 characters needed characters left